Comparing Blue Buffalo Basics and Purina One SmartBlend

Lowest price found: $20.98 Show listings
Lowest price found: $10 Show listings
Consumer Score
In comparison:
Blue Buffalo Basics ranks #30 out of 76. It is in the top 10%.
Go to rankings
9.6
Amazing
Consumer Score
In comparison:
Purina One SmartBlend ranks #4 out of 76. It is in the top 10%.
Go to rankings
10.0
Amazing
Blue Buffalo Basics: Buy | Customer Reviews
Purina One SmartBlend: Buy | Customer Reviews

Customers like Purina One SmartBlend somewhat more

At ReviewFinder we prefer to focus on professional product reviews, because customer reviews can be disproportionately affected by unrelated factors such as delivery, specific seller listing problems, and, of course, fake reviews. With that said, below is the summary of consumer sentiment.

Blue Buffalo Basics
Purina One SmartBlend
Consumer score (CS) is a normalized computed representation of customers' sentiment towards a product.
CS of 10 is similar to a 4.8 star review, CS of 0 is similar to a 2 star review.

Purina One SmartBlend, the cheaper option, tends to get more favorable reviews than Blue Buffalo Basics.

As can be seen in the chart above, median best-selling dog food receives a consumer score of 9.6 (amazing). Both Blue Buffalo Basics and Purina One SmartBlend receive customer reviews that average out above that median threshold.

Blue Buffalo Basics
In comparison:
Blue Buffalo Basics ranks #30 out of 76. It is in the top 10%.
Go to rankings
9.6
Amazing
Purina One SmartBlend
In comparison:
Purina One SmartBlend ranks #4 out of 76. It is in the top 10%.
Go to rankings
10.0
Amazing
Median best-selling Dog Food
In comparison:
Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Stomach ranks #39 out of 76. It is in the top 10%.
Go to rankings
9.6
Amazing





Purina One SmartBlend is more popular than Blue Buffalo Basics

It's fairly safe to say that Purina One SmartBlend is a more popular dog food than Blue Buffalo Basics, based on its 10,000+ reviews. Popularity is determined based on product sales. Note that older and cheaper products tend to sell more.


To consider

Customers who view Blue Buffalo Basics and Purina One SmartBlend often consider IAMS Minichunks, a pricier option.
Table: Top compared alternatives for Blue Buffalo Basics and Purina One SmartBlend
IAMS Minichunks $13
In comparison:
IAMS Minichunks ranks #3 out of 76. It is in the top 10%.
Go to rankings
10.0
Amazing
Purina Focus Large Breed $66
In comparison:
Purina Focus Large Breed ranks #24 out of 76. It is in the top 10%.
Go to rankings
9.6
Amazing
Purina Pro Plan Savor $19
In comparison:
Purina Pro Plan Savor ranks #40 out of 76. It is in the top 10%.
Go to rankings
9.6
Amazing
Purina Pro Plan Sport $19
In comparison:
Purina Pro Plan Sport ranks #8 out of 76. It is in the top 10%.
Go to rankings
10.0
Amazing
Find the best dog food in Dog Food Finder
From Seller:
  • STARTS WITH REAL TURKEY: This grain free adult dry dog food features a single animal protein source along with potatoes, peas and pumpkin to support gentle digestion, making it a good option for dogs with a sensitive stomach
  • Read more
From Seller:
  • One (1) 27.5 lb. Bag - Purina ONE High Protein, Natural Dry Dog Food, True Instinct With Real Turkey & Venison
  • Real turkey is the number 1 ingredient in this dog food with venison to help deliver 30 percent protein that helps support strong muscles, including a healthy heart
  • Read more
From Manufacturer Manufacturer-provided product description, urls and documents.
EAN Numbers: 0781163916642, 0781163917038, 0840243100002, 0840243100026, 0840243100033, 0840243100040, 0840243100057, 0840243100071, 0840243100088, 0840243105441, 0840243105465, 0859610002801, 0859610005789, 0859610005802, 0859610005826, 0859610005833, 0859610005857, 0859610007509, 0859610007523, 0859610007530
Model Numbers: 596250, 596251, 596255, 596261, 596262, 596362, 596365, 596366, 596368, 596369, 596371, BLU00585, BLU10000, BLU10002, BLU10003, BLU10004, BLU10005, BLU10007, BLU10008, BLU10544, BLU10546, BUA-261, BUA-319, BUA-329, BUA-331
UPC Numbers: 781163916642, 781163917038, 840243100002, 840243100026, 840243100033, 840243100040, 840243100057, 840243100071, 840243100088, 840243105441, 840243105465, 859610002801, 859610005789, 859610005802, 859610005826, 859610005833, 859610005857, 859610007509, 859610007523, 859610007530
Model Numbers: 00017800149235, 00017800149372, 00017800149396, 00017800149402, 00017800149419, 00017800154529, 00017800154536, 00017800167468, 00017800171328, 00017800171410, 00017800172516, 00017800173773, 00017800173797, 00017800173803, 00017800173865, 00017800177412, 00017800177436, 00017800177443, 00017800178686, 00017800179768, 00017800179782, 00017800179799, 00017800181983, 00017800182003, 00017800183345, 00017800185592, 00055800116604, 00055800116642, 00055800167644, 00055800215680, 00055800215970, 00055800216076, 00055800290656, 00055800290816, 055800116604, 055800116642, 055800167644, 055800290786, 10017800018897, 17800106368, 17800106382, 17800154550, 17800154574, 178543, 178560, 178586, 178588
EAN Numbers: 0017800018890, 0017800106368, 0017800106405, 0017800129411, 0017800149211, 0017800149235, 0017800149273, 0017800149303, 0017800149327, 0017800149341, 0017800149372, 0017800149396, 0017800149402, 0017800149419, 0017800152938, 0017800154529, 0017800154536, 0017800154543, 0017800154567, 0017800158459, 0017800158497, 0017800158503, 0017800167468, 0017800171410, 0017800172448, 0017800172462, 0017800172516, 0017800173797, 0017800177405, 0017800177429, 0017800177443, 0017800178686, 0017800179751, 0017800179775, 0017800179799, 0017800181983, 0017800182003, 0017800183345, 0017800185592, 0017800475556, 0017800475686, 0017800570114, 0017800570664, 0017800573122, 0055800116604, 0055800116642, 0055800167644, 0055800215680, 0055800215970, 0055800216076, 0055800290526, 0055800290786, 0077344728181, 0640791618178, 0640791618185, 0640791619359, 0640791619373, 0640791619380, 0703774954691, 0713789014914, 0724456972703, 0740023146001, 0740023570011, 0786714128376, 0799554687453, 0799554687507, 0827165733952, 0827165733990, 1133133101555
UPC Numbers: 017800018890, 017800106368, 017800106405, 017800129411, 017800149211, 017800149235, 017800149273, 017800149303, 017800149327, 017800149341, 017800149372, 017800149396, 017800149402, 017800149419, 017800152938, 017800154529, 017800154536, 017800154543, 017800154567, 017800158459, 017800158497, 017800158503, 017800167468, 017800171410, 017800172448, 017800172462, 017800172516, 017800173797, 017800177405, 017800177429, 017800177443, 017800178686, 017800179751, 017800179775, 017800179799, 017800181983, 017800182003, 017800183345, 017800185592, 017800475556, 017800475686, 017800570114, 017800570664, 017800573122, 055800215680, 055800215970, 055800216076, 055800290526, 077344728181, 640791618178, 640791618185, 640791619359, 640791619373, 640791619380, 703774954691, 713789014914, 724456972703, 740023146001, 740023570011, 786714128376, 799554687453, 799554687507, 827165733952, 827165733990
Blue Buffalo Basics: Buy | Customer Reviews
Purina One SmartBlend: Buy | Customer Reviews
Loading price comparison chart...

Blue Buffalo Basics is a popular option at the top of the price range. It's in the top 3 bestselling dog food formulas and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as Purina Focus Large Breed or Purina Focus Weight Management .

Blue Buffalo Basics is $46 more expensive than the average dog food ($19.98).

Purina One SmartBlend is a very popular and one of the cheapest options. It's in the top 3 bestselling dog food formulas and has many popular alternatives in the same price range, such as Nutro Max Grain Free Adult or Nature's Recipe Adult Grain Free .

Purina One SmartBlend is $9.98 less expensive than an average dog food ($19.98).

Blue Buffalo Basics: Buy | Customer Reviews
Purina One SmartBlend: Buy | Customer Reviews

You might also like:

High-rated Dog Food Formulas in a similar price range.

This website displays data from third party public sources. The data presented is for information purposes only. We can't guarantee correctness and completeness of all the data presented here, and therefore will not accept liability for any issues arising from usage of this data. All Trademarks and Copyrights belong to their respective owners. ReviewFinder is reader-supported - if you click on a link on ReviewFinder and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you.


Copyright © 2022